Geology 106 -
OCEANS, WASTE DISPOSAL
Oct. 31
Exam: Scheduled for Tuesday Nov 12.
Ocean Environment - Finish
- Groins, structures and sand movement
- Breakwaters
- Dredging, and Harbor operations
- Human impacts through cumulative effects of individuals
Waste Management, Disposal, Siting, Alternate
Strategies
Waste in Societies
- A direct link to you and your personal
activities
- Past excesses dominate many contaminated
sites (sites now abandoned, or shut town, but that still pose an environmental
threat)
- New owners at these sites (who pays? who's responsible
for remediation?)
Types of waste
- Point source vs non-point source
- Domestic
- Manufacturing
- Mining
- Radioactive* [subject of next lecture]
- Oil and gas production
- Hydrothermal
- Salt and Brine
Geologic Involvement in Waste Disposal
- RECOVERY
- DISPOSAL
- MONITORING & PREDICTION
RECOVERY
Geological recovery of energy, industrial minerals and
metal ores that lead to contamination of the environment (inherently geologic
in its character)
DISPOSAL
Disposal of our modern societal wastes in locations chosen
to minimize the threat to the environment (thus inherently geologic in
its character)
MONITORING AND PREDICTION
Monitoring and predictive modeling of movement of contaminants
in the environment (inherently geologic in its character)
Federal Waste Management related acts
Closely tied to Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA)
EPA's dual role of regulation and investigation.
A potential conflict of interest?
Major acts and laws (from: Testa,
S.M. (1995) Geological Aspects of Hazardous Waste Management; Ann Arbor,
Lewis Publishers
- 1872 Mining Law
- 1970 National Environmental Policy Act
- 1972 Clean Water Act
- 1973 Endangered Species Act
- 1974 Safe Water Drinking Act
- 1976 Toxic Substance Control Act
- 1976 Resource Conservation and Recovery Act
1872 Mining Law
- Written to promote mining and mineral resource development
- One can claim land for minerals while paying no money
for rent or taxes on profits (Depletion allowance for non-renewable resources)
- If vaulable minerals are found company can purchase the
land for $5/acre.
- Law has no provisions for environmental cleanup
- Mining on federal lands accounts for $3-4 billion per
year.
- Managed by BLM and Forest Service.
- 52 mines are currently on the superfund list
- Primary concerns are effects on water quality and transport
of toxic trace metals
Mining Wastes
- Since 1800's significant solid waste provided by mining
activities
- Environmentally hazardous (acid waters, trace metal contamination,
radioactive)
- Indirect contributions from smelting ores created SO2
-> sulfuric acid despoiling of landscape.
- Between 1910 and 1980
- 31 billion metric tons of mine waste
- Waste related to processing of minerals, Sludges
- 13 billion metric tons of mine tailings
- Overburden, rock waste from mine construction
TABLE OF ENVIRONMENTAL CONCERNS CONNECTED
WITH MINING
METAL |
Nol. of Sites |
Quantity of Waste
(million tons/yr)
|
Concerns |
States |
Copper |
19 |
502 |
Elevated metals, low pH |
AZ, NM, UT |
Gold and Silver |
117 |
100 |
Radioactivity |
NV, MT, CA |
Iron |
26 |
177 |
Elevated metals, low pH |
MN, MI, MO |
Lead and Zinc |
23 |
18 |
Residual Cyanide |
MO, TN, ID |
Phosphate |
27 |
403 |
Elevated metals
low pH
|
FL, NC, ID |
Other Metals
Molybdenum
|
24 |
62 |
Elevated metals
low pH
|
CO |
TOTAL |
226 |
1,262 |
|
|
Source: Testa, S.M. (1995) Geological Aspects of Hazardous Waste Management;
Ann Arbor, Lewis Publishers.
1970 - NEPA - National Environmental
Policy Act
- Nixon Signed into Law
- Required EIS (environmental impact statement)
1972 CWA - Clean Water Act
- Control of toxic water pollutants through limits on discharge.
- Includes regulation of discharge into ocean waters within
US jurisdiction
- Excluded the New York Bight sludge dumping
1973 - Endangered Species Act
- Perhaps single most important piece of environmental
legislation.
- Points to the protection of organisms and their environments.
- Has been effectively applied in numerous situations where
environmental threats have appeared (snail darter and TVA, spotted owl
and timbering in NW, ...)
- Considered by some as the single most piece of legislation
threatening development of resources and under severe attack by the 104th
Congress
1974 - SDWA - Safe Drinking Water Act
- Improvement of public water supply systems
- Regulate underground water injection that threatened
public water supplies
- Recognition that chlorinated organics were contaiminating
surface and subsurface supplies of water
- Drinking Water Standards
- Identify drinking water contaminants and specify max
contaminant levels (MCL)
- UIC - Underground Injection Control program
- SSA - Sole Source Aquifers
- Special protection for aquifers that serve as a sole
source of drinking water.
1976 - TSCA - Toxic Substance Control Act
- An information gathering act
- 1- information to identify and evaluate potential chemical
hazards
- 2- Regulation of production, distribution, and disposal.
1976 - RCRA - Resource Conservation and Recovery Act
- Regulates Hazardous and Toxic Wastes
- Provides ìcradle to graveî management of
wastes.
- Employs a permitting procedure requiring geologic and
hydrogeologic site characterization
- Development of detection/monitoring systems.
- Management unit types
- Tanks
- Surface Impoundments
- Waste Piles
- Landfills
- Incinerators
- Underground Injection
- Others
1980 CERCLA - Comprehensive Environmental Response,
Compensation, and Liability Act (Amended 1986) SUPERFUND ACT
- Provides Cradle to Grave management of existing hazardous
waste sites
- Mining, Hazardous Wastes, Landfills, Spills,
- Currently 724 Hazardous Substances List
- 1,500 Radionuclides on the List
- Defines contaminants and pollutants
- Any substance that reasonably may be expected to have
adverse effects on organisms and/or their offspring.
- In 1990 - 1,187 sites chosen from a list of over 33,000
potential sites
- Criticized for lack of results
- Small number of sites declared cleaned up.
- Where did the $$$ go??
SITING OF WASTES
Geologic Aspects of Siting
NATURAL RESOURCES
- Natural resources are where you find them, oil and gas
is where you find it, groundwater is where you find it. (all constitute
uncontrolled variables in that the sites are chosen where the resource
is)
INDUSTRIAL SOURCES
- Aside from many natural substances our modern society
produces many new chemicals (principally organics)
- Many of these chemicals not degradeable in the environment.
- Degradation PRODUCTS are potentially toxic
- Environment not adapted to handle.
WASTE DISPOSAL SITES
- Disposable sites are controlled variables in that you
have a reasonable choice in where you locate them (subject to distances
from where waste is generated, costs of disposal, adequacy of site relative
to local contaminating effects, political pressures (NIMBY)
CHARACTERIZATION & MONITORING
- Hydrogeologic definition and evaluation
- Porosity, permeability, water table, groundwater flow
(direction and rate)
- Chemical characteristics of the aquifer (reactivity with
fluids)
- Geologic Setting
- Nearness to rivers, lakes, nearby housing, industry,
...
- Appropriate monitoring
- Local Groundwater
- Air quality
A COST BENEFIT PROBLEM
- Environmental damage
- Direct
- Indirect, long-term
- Cleanup
- Socio-economic
- Emotional
- Property value effects
- Personal health effects
- NIMBY factors (Not
In My
Back Yard)
- Political
- Decisions are largely unpopular
- Requires compromise among divergent constituencies
Where to put it?
- Into space
- In Ocean Sediments
- Deep well injection (High temp)
- Shallow sub-surface sites
- Burn It
- Store it above ground.
- Find a POSITIVE use for it.
- Natural gas from sanitary landfills
- "V8 Juice"
- Recycling
SLIDES
RETURN TO SYLLABUS